Dealing with Sticking Points Within Mediation
By: Suzanne M. Wagner
You have worked through difficult conversations and reached agreement on several issues, but one disagreement remains. Maybe it involves the family home, a parenting schedule, or how to divide a particular asset. Neither side seems willing to move, and you wonder whether mediation can still work.
A sticking point does not necessarily mean the process has failed. Sometimes progress begins with understanding why an issue matters so much and approaching it differently.
Identify what you really need
During a divorce or custody dispute, it is easy to focus on a specific outcome: “I want the house” or “I need that weekend.” The reason behind that request can be the key to finding a solution.
Wanting the house, for example, may reflect a desire to keep your children in their current school district. A particular weekend may matter because of a longstanding family tradition. Explaining those concerns gives the mediator more information to help explore alternatives that address your priorities.
Before mediation, consider what matters most to you, why it matters, and where you have flexibility.
Make room for the emotional side
Family law disputes involve more than financial figures and calendar dates. Frustration, grief, and feeling unheard can make it difficult to evaluate even a reasonable proposal.
If an issue carries emotional weight, discuss it with your attorney beforehand. Understanding that background can help your attorney and the mediator approach the conversation more productively. Sometimes having a meaningful opportunity to explain a concern makes it easier to begin discussing solutions.
Explore a different way forward
When a discussion stalls, repeating the same proposal may not help. Depending on the issue, the next step might include:
- Looking at the bigger picture. A disagreement over one parenting weekend may be easier to resolve by considering holidays and other weekends throughout the year.
- Gathering more information. A budget can help you assess whether keeping the family home is financially realistic.
- Meeting privately with the mediator. A separate conversation can provide space to discuss concerns and consider options.
- Consulting another professional. A financial or parenting specialist may help clarify an issue that is preventing agreement.
- Taking a break. Addressing another issue or allowing time for reflection can make a later conversation more productive.
You do not need to arrive with every answer. Being prepared to explain your concerns and consider alternatives can help the process move forward.
Consider how a proposal will work in daily life
A settlement should address more than the disagreement in front of you. Think about whether you can afford the proposed financial arrangement, how a parenting schedule will function, and what your family will need in the months ahead.
For parents, those decisions also affect an ongoing co-parenting relationship. Keeping your children’s needs and your family’s future in view can help you evaluate whether a proposed compromise is workable.
Prepare with your attorney
Before mediation, ask your attorney what to expect, which documents to bring, and what the possible next steps would be if you do not reach agreement. Understanding the potential costs, risks, and outcomes of litigation can help you make informed decisions during negotiations.
A difficult issue may require more time, information, or a different approach. The goal is a resolution you understand and can put into practice.
Attorney Suzanne Wagner, Certified Family Law Specialist and Registered Family Law Mediator, recently explored these topics as a panelist for “Dealing with Sticking Points within Mediation” at the Family Law Institute in Indianapolis on November 13, 2026.